Cloud strife crossdresser-Why is Cloud dressing up as a lady transphobic? - Final Fantasy VII - Giant Bomb

A lot has changed since I was thirteen, and I nervously checked to see if anyone else was home. Looking back, it seems a little ridiculous, but I really was afraid someone could glean something like that about me, just from playing a game where the main character is forced to crossdress. I know now that I was a girl, but that understanding and framing only came much later. Crossdressing is most certainly not the same experience as being trans, but strict expectations about gender conformity and "acceptable" expression absolutely do affect trans people.

Cloud strife crossdresser

Cloud strife crossdresser

Cloud strife crossdresser

Cloud strife crossdresser

Wearing lipstick, eyeshadow, calling himself a "bad girl" and equipping female-only equipment along with his troupe bangaa are always considered to be male for gameplay purposes, thus unable to equip these accessories through normal means. Cloud is a man. My guess, and this is not my preference just my prediction, Cloud strife crossdresser that they just cut the whole thing to avoid the headaches of doing it well. Though TV can make it super gross there was some "shemale or female" segment on an american show that is horrible. Categories :.

Virgin air nairobi jobs. Crossdressing!Cloud

Your opponent usually has around 17 squats, so try and Oral hiv tests that. The building on the left is the bar. Start a Wiki. I'm not sure why though. If used as a Dancer, the Dragqueen's sprite and portrait will use the Bard's set with the job command " Dance ". He professed that he and his team felt hesitant that they could pull off a remake of this scope, especially since they've all become much older since the original title. Now everything should be perfect. Now, depending on who's chosen, you're either with Cloud in the room with Corneo's lackeys, or Cloud is in the Don's bedroom. The Seamstress Clothes appear as a green dress when worn, even if the character wearing them is one of the two male party members Brandt and Jusqua. I never stop laughing to that hilarious scene. The building on the right is the Weapon Shop, which sells some things you haven't seen yet. Please do not Cloud strife crossdresser rude, what may be obvious to you may not be to Cloud strife crossdresser. Image size. These are not usually tested by us because there are so manyso please use them at your own risk.

Faris Scherwiz crossdresses as a man in Final Fantasy V.

  • When the Final Fantasy VII Remake was announced, most fans felt exuberant joy, overwhelmed with happiness that the dreamed-of remake would finally be happening.
  • Wall Market's a big place and you can easily get lost.
  • See More by HeavyMetalHanzo.
  • Faris Scherwiz crossdresses as a man in Final Fantasy V.

While I do think Square will rework parts of FF7 hopefully limited to gameplay and translation. One thing I see repeatedly mentioned is that some people want them to change Barret's character as well as remove the sequence where you find items for Cloud to crossdress in order to save Tifa. I'm not saying that they're wrong but I do want to understand why these elements are so offensive. Edit: For a great take on the subject check out this piece by Sarah Nyberg. Barret has long been viewed as a stereotypical angry black man with a gun.

I personally think that is selling his character short, but that particular complaint does have some history to it, and isn't just tumblr being offended by something it just discovered.

If I recall correctly, it was not Cloud dressing up as a woman that offended people, it was the conversations you had with the NPC's and their feelings about it. There were a few NPC characters that outright made fun of Cloud for wearing women's clothing which could have people read into that sequence of the game being trans phobic.

Maybe Barret is just an angry man with a gun? Maybe the ones bringing up the fact that he's black are the stereotypical ones, not square themselves. I think his skin color is and always has been irrelevant. He's just a pissed off man who's seen some shit and fought in a lot of battles. That could make anyone angry all the time. Also, I have seen people bring up the Cloud in a dress thing and the fact that it made them uncomfortable.

They're weird and they can get over it, keep that scene in I say. I really do want that snowboarding scene gone though. Terrible mini game. Also, keep the escape from midgar mortorcycle scene, but just make it a cutscene, not a mini game. I haven't heard of that moment being called offensive though I can understand the reasoning behind it.

I did see some disappointment at the quick Fallout 4 guy in a dress bit, which is similar. From what I understand its about how its framed. In the brief Fallout 4 moment It was framed less as "you can where all of these costumes, how cool is that! I've never played FF7 so I can't really say anything about that particular scene.

Barrett has pretty good reason's for being pissed off. His skin colour has nothing to do with it. Of course Cloud is going to be made fun of for dressing like a girl. He's in the slums of a megacity, in a rough night life area with a brothel. You think the people there are going to be open minded? The dudes in the Gym are totally on board with the entire venture though, so there's people there who support you, not to mention the people who make you the dress, give you the perfect wig and the perfume.

That is the argument I've heard. The punchline of the Cloud in drag scene is just "look at that dude in a dress and how silly he looks! I mean Don Corneo is a sexual predator and he's comic relief multiple times. That shit is kinda fucked. Ehh, I don't know if you peeps in here are seeing the whole picture with Barrett. His dialogue is basically chock full of lazy Blaxploitation style stereotypes, and the fact that no one else in that world even remotely talks like him makes it impossible for his character to have developed naturally in a way that makes him believable.

The dress-up sequence containing transphobic elements I can't speak to. Even though I replayed FF7 earlier this year I have no recollection of anything objectionable.

One of my trans friends finds transvestites highly offensive, but I disagree as much as my opinion on this can count for anything, right?

In this case it is simply cross dressing, a different but related thing, but I can see her point of view that it is an assault on her identity because it causes people to continue to view it as pretending to be something you're not. It's an insecurity that shouldn't dictate whether it is right or wrong for anyone of any gender to cross dress for their own personal enjoyment, kink or comfort. In the case of FF7, it is to fool someone. There is what I see as a legitimate split between people who find the idea of a 'trap' offensive, and those who embrace it.

Again though, in this scenario it isn't 'fooling' for the sake of humiliation. It's for infiltration purposes. There will still be disagreement on this but that is always the case, you can't convince everyone. It's an acceptable part of the story that makes some missteps but that doesn't invalidate the entire idea.

I think transvestites are open to conversation because it is making a spectacle of gender norms mixing for mockery. I might still side with the ability for someone to enjoy being seen as the opposite gender in an exaggerated way for entertainment value. Though TV can make it super gross there was some "shemale or female" segment on an american show that is horrible.

Barrett's dialogue is clearly patterned after stereotypes about how African American men speak and act. I'm not sure how you can really read it and not think it's racist. His fundamental character is fine, even likeable, but all that dialogue has to be rewritten or it's going to be a huge problem. The cloud transvestite sequence is played for laughs and also contains transphobic comments and attitudes. It's not that you could never do that in a game in a sensitive manner, but no attempt to be sensitive is made in FFVII.

It's hard to do it right, and they just sort of don't worry about it and play it for fun. This is cis privilege. It's not intended as transphobic but it comes off as insensitive. It's hard to do it right. My guess, and this is not my preference just my prediction, is that they just cut the whole thing to avoid the headaches of doing it well.

Playing men crossdressing as comedy is considered transphobic. I'd be sad to see the sequence go, as it's a part of my child hood, and similarly I'd be sad if they changed Barret, but I also won't mourn too loudly if they are heavily changed and updated to fit better with a modern context. There are other wacky ways to break into the Don's mansion that would keep that sequence's lighthearted, funny tone, which I am way more worried about losing than anything to do with crossdressing.

Also, Barret, even then, was hella racist. I love Barret. I'm a little racist. I can let this one go. The bit with Cloud crossdressing is not transphobic, because crossdressing in and of itself has no bearing at all on trans-ness.

To borrow a phrase; it's not about your hardware, but the software in your heart. Cloud is male. Cloud is a man. Cloud finds himself in a weird situation where he does something outside of his comfort zone dressing up as the opposite gender in order to complete a task. Hilarity ensues because in comedy, often the best laughs stem from breaking social taboos and, still to this day, crossdressing is a pretty big one.

It's cute. It's cheeky. It's humorous. The one thing that it is not is a commentary on trans individuals. In fact I'd venture to say it has nothing to do with transgender individuals. Crossdressing is its own thing.

As far as Barrett goes, that's a whole other can of worms. I'd like to see him remain unchanged because I liked the guy, but if Square caves to the wailing I won't blame them. It is, in the context of an American audience, a rather insensitive portrayal of a black man. They aren't going to cut that part from the game come on people.

This is a japanese game and they clearly don't give a FUCK about western gender politics. Also the sheer work required would be crazy. As DonChipotle said they'd have to remove the whole Honeybee Inn thing, they'd have to find some other reason Tifa goes into Don Cornelio's hideout, have to come up with some other way to get into the hideout entirely, etc, etc. There is just too much work to try and appease a vocal but still niche group when they can just leave it in let everyone just deal with it.

I would say it is transphobic as it plays on the whole trap stereotype. Which is admittedly harmful. The whole framing of it as a joke is also not great, but less an issue for me personally. It would be really cool if Square addressed this scene and done something different, for example using Tifa or Aerith in that same role. Yeah, if you acknowledge that racism might exist then obviously you're the real racist. Not really the part I was talking about there buddy. I mean that in the grand scheme of who Barret is, his skin color has always been damn near completely irrelevant.

However, the parts of his character that stand out as being stereotypical have almost nothing to do with his compelling character arcs. He can still have a complex relationship with his adoptive daughter and her biological father and not say shit like "Shit!

The hell you so calm about? You bustin' up my rhythm He is the only person that talks that way in ordinary conversation and I think it was a bit of lazy writing on Square's part.

Was this in the original or part of the localization?

The one for is, of course, the best. Developer's Office - Fourth wall - Moai. However, if you want Cloud or Aeris to be picked, there's a bunch more Key Items to be gotten. Though the law forbids the player's clan from harming the opposite gender in that battle, if a male character attacks the Night Dancer, the law will not be broken. Join the community to add your comment. Now you must make a choice.

Cloud strife crossdresser

Cloud strife crossdresser

Cloud strife crossdresser. Crossdressing at Wall Market

Nobody's perfect! I never stop laughing to that hilarious scene. ElixaElixir Hobbyist Digital Artist. I love this way more than I should. I would have had no problem with Cloud completing the game in a dress. I know they're releasing the original PC version; but if they ever do remake the game, this could be a great alternate outfit. It would be funny yeah :. Vagrant-Skull Professional Digital Artist. This is amazing. Thank you. Laugh-Butts Professional Digital Artist.

WoodSpider Student General Artist. I think they prefer the term 'escort' There can never be enough of this concept. This picture makes me want a 7 remake even more, so funny when cloud gets picked. I'll chop them off Great pic! Gihn Hobbyist General Artist. And if you got all the right accessories the don would pick him above Tifa and Arise.

I guess the don didn't want a poor, dirty, smelly, street gal Head over to the restaurant left of the Save Point and order a menu. Either Korean B. Plate, Sushi Plate, or Today's Special. They all cost 70 gil. Head over to the Item Shop.

You can select Disinfectant, Deodorant, or Digestive here for the Coupon. Choose Digestive and give it to the woman on the toilet in the bar. Now it's time to get another extra, a Tiara. Head over to the Materia Shop, which is north from the Save Point. Help him out, and head to the Inn, near the south entrance. Stay at the Inn costs 10 Gil , and buy something for either , or 50 gil. The one for is, of course, the best. Head back to the Materia Shop owner and show him what you got.

Head all the way south and talk to the guy on the lower right. He'll give you his 'Member's Card' for the Honeybee Inn, just like that! Now head right, and.. Talk to the girl, and choose a room.. The Lover's Room upper right and the Queen's Room lower right are both occupied, but you can take a peek or listen to see a scene. Move your view through the Keyhole slightly.. Okay, let's move on. Now everything should be perfect.. Head out, make your way to the dress shop, and change by walking to the change room.

Now you can finally enter Don Corneo's Mansion to the north. Once inside, head upstairs and head to the left, down into the basement. You'll find Tifa and an Ether here.

After the dialog and getting the Ether just head upstairs again, and through the middle door. Now, depending on who's chosen, you're either with Cloud in the room with Corneo's lackeys, or Cloud is in the Don's bedroom. If you're with the lackeys, just talk to all of them and get the Phoenix Down. Cloud will reveal he's a guy.. After this, head through the middle door and into the Don's bedroom.

In the Don's bedroom, some dialog will happen, but be sure to get the well hidden Hyper behind the bed. If Cloud got chosen, you'll be able to get the Phoenix Down from the other room, some other time. After the dialog, when you attempt to leave, you're given three options to choose from, but all three will lead you to the same fate.. This site is not affiliated in any way with Microsoft, Sony, Sega, Nintendo or any video game publishers. Privacy Policy Terms of Service. Super Cheats is an unofficial resource with submissions provided by members of the public.

These are not usually tested by us because there are so many , so please use them at your own risk. View Desktop Site. Your Account. Not registered? Sign Up for free. Registration allows you to keep track of all your content and comments, save bookmarks, and post in all our forums. More Content. Game Search. Game Guides. Latest Updates. Pokemon Alola Anime Series Conclu.. Conan O'Brien is now officially i.. Pokemon Go Battle League will int.. American Dad! Apocalypse Soon walkthro..

Doraemon: Story of Seasons walkthrough.. Idle Fitness Gym Tycoon walkthrough an.. Zooba: Zoo Battle Arena walkthrough an.. Ask a question here Help a gamer Can you provide the answers for fellow gamers questions. Upcoming games for What are you looking forward to?

Pokemon Go Posts How many have you caught? Latest Team Posts What new on the Teams forums. Pokemon News and updates Keep informed and updated Pokemon Giveaway Our pokemon experts can help you. Follow the dark path or use the light. Remember Me Forgot Password. Sign Up. Guides Cheats Answers Forums. What's New on SuperCheats? Comments for Crossdressing at Wall Market. Add your comment here. Characters left: Please do not be rude, what may be obvious to you may not be to others.

Please login to post a comment. Login above or Click here to sign up for free.

Worth Reading: A Close Look At Final Fantasy VII’s Crossdressing Scene

A lot has changed since I was thirteen, and I nervously checked to see if anyone else was home. Looking back, it seems a little ridiculous, but I really was afraid someone could glean something like that about me, just from playing a game where the main character is forced to crossdress. I know now that I was a girl, but that understanding and framing only came much later.

Crossdressing is most certainly not the same experience as being trans, but strict expectations about gender conformity and "acceptable" expression absolutely do affect trans people. Positive portrayals of both crossdressing and trans characters in games are becoming more and more common, even just within the past year or so. A recent Guild Wars 2 patch added a trans woman character. There have, unfortunately, been a good number of missteps along the way as well.

It felt appropriate to petition the company to remove the content, which had no real redeeming value other than punching down at a marginalized group for the sake of cheap laughs. The scene in Final Fantasy VII starts after a mission goes awry and Cloud is separated from some members of his party.

At first Cloud is resistant to the idea of dressing like a girl, but as the player you undergo a series of quests to acquire the right accessories to be a convincing one. At the very least, you're required to collect a dress and a wig; additional items include a cologne, tiara, and undergarments.

The specific combinations can result in Don Corneo picking either Tifa, Aeris or Cloud to come with him to his bedroom. Getting the Don to choose Cloud is actually the most difficult, requiring you to win the mini-games and make the most optimal choices as you navigate Wall Market looking for precisely the right items.

To get the dress, you have to locate the father of a clothing store in a bar. You learn he's become disillusioned with "making regular clothes" after Aeris explains that Cloud's "always said that just once, he'd like to dress up as a girl. After getting the the dress made, Cloud tries it on in a dressing room but Aeris thinks something is missing, and agrees he needs to find a wig. The shop owner explains that at the gym, you'll find "a lot of people there like you" who can help you out.

A few smaller tasks are completed for the cologne and tiara. The ordeal for the undergarments is probably the strangest of the bunch, however: the "Honey Bee Inn" brothel that supplies Don Corneo with the three women he chooses from every day has a series of rooms you can choose from. In the Group Room, the men invite Cloud to "wash off our sweat and dirt together.

Mukki, one of the men, asks, "How is it, bubby?! Feels good, huh? This has been read by various people as either referring to the hot tub itself perhaps being too hot, a too-intense massage or sexual assault. Regardless of your choice of dialogue, Cloud responds by saying, "I don't feel good. Let me out It's the most unfortunate part of all of Wall Market; the recurring joke throughout the crossdressing ordeal is Cloud's and, presumably, the player's discomfort—that the challenge, in a sense, is to endure that discomfort for the sake of others.

For a lot of people, this optional scene is what shifted the tenor of the Wall Market sequence from goofy humor at Cloud's unfortunate circumstances to the game portraying the gay men as predatory and creepy. It partially taints not only one of the few representations of a group of queer characters in a game that old, but also paints crossdressers similarly by association as well; these men, after all, are where Cloud acquires the bikini briefs for his mission to infiltrate Don Corneo's mansion.

Cloud goes back to the dress shop and changes, becoming "Miss Cloud. After he asks Miss Cloud for a kiss, Aeris and Tifa break in and Cloud reveals himself as a man before all three take turns threatening to do various things to his genitals to extract information from him about ShinRa. Throughout the entire ordeal, Aeris follows you and is excited, flirty and encouraging.

People in the town are occasionally surprised, but never overtly bigoted or hostile. You […]. Zoya Street, curator of Critical Distance, offers slow reflections on the fast-paced world of digital play…. As long as there are light switches in the house or voice-activated prompts, or whatever the future brings , people are going to need an electrician. Every artist, budding or established, has a sketchbook. The How to Draw series of sketchbooks are a well-designed alternative to rote linework or idle doodling, incorporating […].

Read the rules you agree to by using this website in our Terms of Service. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon. Boing Boing uses cookies and analytics trackers, and is supported by advertising, merchandise sales and affiliate links. Read about what we do with the data we gather in our Privacy Policy.

Who will be eaten first? Our forum rules are detailed in the Community Guidelines. Boing Boing is published under a Creative Commons license except where otherwise noted. Jason Weisberger Publisher. Ken Snider Sysadmin. By Sarah Nyberg. This electrical engineering training will help you with those at home repairs As long as there are light switches in the house or voice-activated prompts, or whatever the future brings , people are going to need an electrician.

Cloud strife crossdresser